Pastors and church leaders often focus on those who seem most spiritually receptive—the seekers, the hurting, and the curious. But in 2003, I developed what became known as the Rainer Scale, a framework that helps churches understand the varying levels of receptivity among unchurched people.
Over the past two decades, as we have applied this scale in thousands of contexts, a surprising insight has emerged. The largest mission field is not the eager or the resistant. It is the neutral middle—the group we identify as the U3.
These individuals are neither pursuing faith nor running from it. They are simply living life without giving church much thought. Yet despite their silence, they represent one-third of the entire unchurched population, an estimated 30 to 35 million Americans.
U3s do not respond to big campaigns or aggressive strategies. But they are remarkably open when approached with relationships, consistency, and genuine care.
They are, in many ways, the hidden unchurched harvest, waiting quietly on the edges of our communities. Here are some facts about the U3 that will help you understand them and reach them.
They Are Not Opposed to Church — They Are Disconnected
One of the most surprising realities about the U3 is how little hostility they carry toward the church. These men and women are not angry, wounded, or spiritually resistant. They are simply disconnected.
Faith and church life operate somewhere in the background of their minds, not because of bitterness, but because they have slowly drifted into a life where spiritual involvement no longer feels relevant. Their neutrality is not a reaction—it is a habit.
This group doesn’t stay away because they object to Christianity. Rather, church has become a non-factor in their weekly routines. The rhythms of work, school, family, and personal interests quietly crowd out spiritual engagement.
As a result, the U3 are not asking spiritual questions, but they are not avoiding them either. This calm neutrality makes them surprisingly approachable once a personal relationship nudges faith back into their field of vision.
They Are Busy, Distracted, and Overscheduled
A defining characteristic of the U3 is not spiritual resistance but life congestion. They are often overcommitted, juggling work, school schedules, children’s activities, and the constant pull of digital distractions. Their absence from church is rarely intentional—it is simply the byproduct of a crowded life.
Most U3 individuals are not rejecting faith. They are just tired. Their calendars feel full, their routines feel fixed, and adding one more commitment seems impossible. Spiritual habits get pushed aside not out of opposition, but because they feel they have no margin.
This busyness creates a subtle barrier. They may be open to church, but they are not actively seeking it. Yet the very pressures that keep them away can also become open doors. When a trusted person reaches out with care, or when life slows just enough for reflection, the U3 often respond with surprising receptivity.
They Have Minimal Recent Church Exposure
The U3 are not absent from church because of conflict or trauma. They simply have little recent exposure to church life. Many were once connected—perhaps through childhood attendance, family traditions, or sporadic involvement—but they drifted quietly over time. Their distance is gradual, not dramatic.
Because of this drift, the church has faded from their weekly rhythms. They are not keeping up with sermons, events, or ministries. Most haven’t had a meaningful spiritual conversation in years. Yet this lack of exposure also means they have very few barriers. They are not weighed down by negative experiences—they are simply unfamiliar. And unfamiliarity can be overcome quickly through intentional relationships and clear, welcoming communication.
Their Lives Are Stable Enough to Ignore Spiritual Questions (for Now)
A key characteristic of the U3 is the appearance of relative stability. Their lives are not perfect, but they function smoothly enough that deeper spiritual questions remain unaddressed. Many have steady jobs, predictable routines, and supportive relationships.
They are not necessarily thriving, but they are managing. Because there is no immediate crisis, faith feels optional rather than essential.
This sense of stability creates a subtle barrier to engagement. When life is comfortable, spiritual urgency fades. Church involvement slips from “important” to merely “helpful,” and eventually to “unnecessary.”
The U3 rarely articulate this shift; it happens quietly as daily responsibilities overshadow deeper concerns. They are not consciously choosing a secular life. They are simply choosing the next task on the calendar.
Yet this stability is more fragile than it appears. Job changes, health concerns, moves, relational strain, or parenting challenges can quickly create moments of receptivity. When life transitions happen, the U3 often feel them more deeply because they lack a spiritual anchor.
This is where the church’s presence matters most. A gentle invitation during a transition—or even before it—can move a neutral, stable individual toward renewed openness to the gospel.
They Respond to Relationships More Than Programs
One of the strongest traits of the U3 is their response to relationships rather than programming. Traditional church efforts—advertising campaigns, large events, or broad invitations—rarely move them. These individuals are not looking for another activity to fit into an already full schedule.
But they do respond to people.
A simple conversation, a thoughtful gesture, or a meaningful invitation from someone they trust can open doors that no program ever could. The U3 value authenticity. They want to know that the person inviting them genuinely cares before they consider taking a step toward church.
This relational responsiveness is not only a pathway toward engagement; it is often the only pathway. When churches focus on consistent, personal connections—neighbors, coworkers, classmates, and extended family—U3 individuals begin to see church not as an institution but as a community worth exploring.
They Avoid Institutions but Value Community
A defining feature of the U3 is their skepticism toward institutions. They are not hostile, but they are cautious. Traditional structures—whether governmental, educational, or religious—feel distant and impersonal to them. This hesitancy includes the church. They may respect the idea of church, but they are unsure how it fits into their lives.
Yet, in a seeming contradiction, these same individuals deeply value community. They long for belonging, relationships, and meaningful connection. They want friendships they can trust and people who will walk with them through life. What they resist is formality; what they welcome is authenticity.
This tension presents both a challenge and an opportunity. Programs alone won’t move them, but genuine community will. When churches demonstrate warmth, care, and consistency—not just structure—the U3 begin to lean in. They are drawn more to people living out their faith than to the institutional expression of faith itself.
They Convert Slowly — but They Stay When They Do
Perhaps the most encouraging reality about the U3 is not how they begin their faith journey, but how they continue it. U3 individuals rarely respond quickly. They move toward spiritual engagement gradually—often through repeated conversations, steady relationships, or unexpected life transitions. Their progress is slow, but it is real. And once they take a step toward Christ or toward the church, they tend to remain steady and committed.
This slow pace can frustrate churches that desire immediate results. But the U3 remind us that spiritual formation is often a process, not an event. They need time to rebuild trust, to ask honest questions, and to see faith lived out consistently. When they do, something remarkable happens: neutrality shifts to openness, and openness becomes genuine receptivity.
For this reason, the U3 may represent the greatest long-term harvest in our communities. They do not respond to quick fixes, but they are deeply moved by patient, faithful, relational ministry. If churches will stay present—day after day and conversation after conversation—the hidden unchurched harvest becomes not just possible, but abundant.
Posted on December 8, 2025
With nearly 40 years of ministry experience, Thom Rainer has spent a lifetime committed to the growth and health of local churches across North America.
More from Thom
