Most pastors don’t need encouragement to buy books. They need help figuring out where to put them.
That reality surfaced recently in a thoughtful thread on Church Answers Central, our membership hub (see this link to join). Pastors asked good questions. They shared real constraints. Shelves. Offices. Time. And a common challenge: How do I organize a growing library so it actually serves my ministry?
I’m grateful for every comment and follow-up question in that conversation. The collective wisdom was strong. What follows, however, focuses primarily on the approach I recommended.
The goal is not perfection.
The goal is usefulness.
Start with broad categories—not too many.
If your library has grown by several hundred volumes, simplicity becomes your ally.
Resist the temptation to create dozens of narrow classifications. You’re not running a seminary library. You’re serving a local church.
A helpful target is 8–12 major categories. That number provides enough structure to find what you need without creating unnecessary complexity.
Here is a sample framework that works well for many pastors:
- Biblical Studies (Old Testament / New Testament)
- Theology
- Church History
- Pastoral Ministry & Leadership
- Preaching & Teaching
- Spiritual Formation
- Biography & Memoir
- Culture, Ethics, and Apologetics
- Reference
That list may flex slightly depending on your ministry context. Some pastors add missions. Others add counseling. That’s fine.
The key is restraint. Fewer categories mean less decision fatigue and faster access.
Sub-organize only where volume demands it.
Once your major categories are in place, pause before adding layers.
Not every section needs subdivision. But when a category grows large, light structure can be helpful—as long as it remains intuitive.
Here are a few examples that tend to work well:
- Biblical Studies
- Old Testament arranged by canonical order
- New Testament arranged by canonical order
- Theology
- Organized by discipline (systematic, biblical, historical, practical)
- Church History
- Organized by era or movement
- Practical Ministry & Leadership
- Organized by topic (evangelism, prayer, leadership, administration, counseling, church health)
Notice what’s missing.
There’s no complex numbering system. No technical cataloging language.
You are organizing for use, not accreditation.
If you have to stop and think too long about where a book belongs, the system is too complicated.
Keep frequent-use authors together.
One of the most overlooked principles of library organization is habit.
Most pastors return to the same trusted voices again and again—especially for commentaries, theology, and preaching helps.
Within each category, consider grouping authors you use frequently rather than dispersing them alphabetically across the shelf.
Why?
Because when sermon prep pressure is high, familiarity saves time.
So does muscle memory.
You already know which writers you reach for when the clock is ticking. Let your shelves reflect that reality.
This approach doesn’t break order; it serves it.
Create a “prime shelf.”
Every effective study has a power zone.
Reserve the shelves closest to your desk for what you use weekly, not what looks impressive.
Your prime shelf might include:
- Current commentary sets
- Books tied to your present sermon series
- Go-to preaching and teaching resources
- A small collection of formative works you reference often
These books should be reachable without standing up—or at least without a ladder.
If a resource hasn’t been touched in years, it doesn’t belong in prime real estate.
Avoid overly technical systems.
It’s tempting to adopt a formal classification system. Some pastors try. Most abandon it.
Here’s the honest question: Will this system still make sense when you’re tired on a Saturday night?
If the answer is no, simplify.
Your library exists to support prayer, preaching, leadership, and care for people—not to demonstrate cataloging precision.
A “good enough” system that you actually maintain is far better than an elegant system you quietly ignore.
Revisit the system periodically.
Libraries are living things.
Every year or two, take a short walk through your shelves and ask:
- What categories need expanding?
- What books could move out of prime space?
- What no longer serves your current ministry season?
You don’t need a major overhaul. Small adjustments keep the system healthy.
A final word of gratitude
The conversation that sparked this article is a reminder of why Church Answers Central matters. Pastors helping pastors. Honest questions. Practical wisdom.
I’m thankful for those who asked, commented, and pressed for clarity. Your engagement sharpened the discussion—and, I hope, this article.
A well-organized library doesn’t make you a better pastor.
But it does remove friction. It saves time.
And it lets your books serve you—rather than the other way around.
What can you add about organizing a library?
Posted on February 9, 2026
With nearly 40 years of ministry experience, Thom Rainer has spent a lifetime committed to the growth and health of local churches across North America.
More from Thom
